‘No force behind the saber’: Congress should ignore tough talk from Trump admin, legal experts say

Posted

A federal prosecutor says he’s pre-investigating potential future crimes by Democratic lawmakers who might one day abuse their oversight powers.

The notion is so farcical it should simply be ignored, say six experts in congressional power and constitutional law.

U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz, the Trump-appointed top prosecutor in south Texas, sent letters to four senators and a House member — all Democrats expected to wield powerful gavels in January — suggesting that their vows to aggressively investigate President Donald Trump’s allies could lead to criminal probes and charges.

Veterans of executive-legislative clashes say Reitz’s letters are legally meritless. There’s simply no crime, they say, when a member of Congress describes possible future oversight actions — even aggressive or controversial ones. And when they take the majority, those lawmakers’ investigative actions would be protected by one of the most powerful immunities in government: the Constitution’s speech or debate clause.

“They’re saber-rattling, but there’s no force behind the saber,” said Stan Brand, a former House general counsel under Speaker Tip O’Neill, who said Democrats should disregard the letters and avoid “adding a patina of legitimacy to what is essentially crackpot legal practice.”

Reitz’s letters to the five lawmakers — Sens. Elissa Slotkin, Elizabeth Warren, Richard Blumenthaland Adam Schiff, as well as Rep. Robert Garcia — have raised eyebrows in Washington for the suggestion that lawmakers’ pre-election comments about investigating Trump allies could amount to criminal intimidation.

Democrats targeted by Reitz have vowed to push forward with their investigations and reject his attempt to criminalize what they say are their constitutional rights and duties. On Wednesday, Slotkin in a post on social media urged him to “bring it on."

"If there's a legal case to be made that you should prosecute someone for freedom of speech, do it. Come get me," Slotkin said in a video.

The Justice Department has stood by Reitz, a former chief of staff to Sen. Ted Cruz and aide to outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, defending the substance of his letters.

“Oversight is not a license to threaten private citizens for exercising their First Amendment rights,” the Justice Department said in a statement that cited the same criminal statute referenced by Reitz. “Congress gave DOJ the authority to investigate those who willfully deprive people of their constitutional rights.”

But legal experts say the Hill shouldn’t sweat it.

“I’d largely ignore it and not give it air,” said one white collar attorney who spoke on the condition of anonymity because he previously represented Trump allies. A second attorney who has been active in congressional oversight matters said the latest spate of attacks from the White House and Justice Department is “even more laughable than usual.”

“Congress has extremely broad latitude to conduct oversight of the executive branch, and … the Speech or Debate Clause provides Congress, its committees, its members, and its staff (when functioning at the direction of the members) with a shield against any executive branch efforts to impede that oversight,” said Steven Huefner, an Ohio State University law professor who spent five years in the office of the Senate’s legal counsel from 1995-2000. “I therefore think that Congress can ignore the recent threats.”

Steve Vladeck, a Georgetown University law professor, said Reitz’s letters are “so clumsy and over the top” that they would be unlikely to provoke a serious legal clash between the branches. He said serious challenges to Congress’ authority are likely to develop later, once Democrats begin exercising their oversight power.

“It has seemed inevitable since long before Election Day that the Trump administration would take an incredibly combative approach against any efforts on Congress’s part to exercise even traditional forms of oversight over the executive branch,” Vladeck said. “The odds that, somewhere along the way, that approach provokes novel and serious Speech or Debate Clause issues seem as high as the odds that they’ll provoke novel questions about executive privilege, Congress’s legitimate investigative powers, and everything in between.”

Reitz said in a statement Tuesday that he’s simply following “the facts and law” by sending letters that ask lawmakers to preserve relevant documents.

After a left-leaning group filed a bar complaint against him this week, Reitz vowed to “continue my preliminary inquiry unfazed: to determine whether certain members of Congress have unlawfully stepped outside the legitimate legislative purpose of their planned committee activities, and to ensure Americans’ constitutional rights are protected.”

At the heart of the administration’s position are two longstanding principles: All congressional investigations and subpoenas must be tethered to a “legitimate legislative purpose,” and the Constitution’s speech or debate clause — intended to protect lawmakers from intimidation or coercion from the executive branch — applies only to a “narrow” slice of core legislative activity and not to broader conduct by lawmakers, like media interviews or subpoenas issued for improper purposes.

“I have taken routine, pre-investigatory steps to conduct a preliminary inquiry into certain members of congress for their statements vowing to weaponize committee activities against private citizens and entities associated with President Trump,” Reitz said in a statement, describing his letters as being sent “in coordination with Main Justice.”

A Justice Department official, speaking on condition of anonymity to describe the department’s internal deliberations, said there was nothing amiss about Reitz’s pre-review of potential oversight abuses.

“Sending threatening letters to Americans for associating with the President — before those officials have oversight power — is a clear attempt to chill associational rights and speech,” the official said. “And, yes, it is a valid exercise of DOJ’s prosecutorial power to prevent ‘anyone acting under the color of law to willfully deprive a person of their constitutional or federal rights.’”

Reitz’s letters have gotten some public backup from Trent McCotter, the Department of Justice’s second-in-command, who echoed the claim that the senators’ comments could violate Trump allies’ First Amendment rights. “DOJ will defend against threats to those rights,” McCotter wrote on X.

Reitz’s letters followed a similar missive from White House counsel Will Scharf to Rep. Robert Garcia, who is slated to lead the House Oversight Committee in January. Scharf’s letter borrowed language from a federal criminal statute to warn the California Democrat against aggressive investigations.

“[T]hreats to executive branch officials designed to deter them from public service, or process designed merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient may cross the line into blatant criminality,” Scharf wrote.

Though constitutional law experts say DOJ’s position is unlikely to clip Congress’ oversight ambitions, the battle for public opinion is another matter. Trump, they noted, has effectively countered congressional probes and impeachment efforts by pointing to Democrats’ own commentary and casting the investigations as “lawfare” or “weaponization” against him and his allies.

Through that lens, the attacks from the White House and Justice Department could be more effective. The administration’s letters point to loose comments from incoming House Democrats about raining down subpoenas like “Mardi Gras beads” or imploring Trump allies to “lawyer up.” Garcia jokingly described his future oversight plans as the result of “pettiness,” a comment that Scharf and Reitz both seized on.

Those comments could cost Democrats public support, some experts say, and also form the backbone of the administration’s litigation strategy against subpoenas they claim are not tied to a “legitimate legislative purpose.”

But the messaging fight is unlikely to translate into legal victories, they say. Though courts have paid attention to stray comments from Democrats during previous investigations, they have almost uniformly affirmed Congress’ broad power to obtain information.

So long as lawmakers embrace a plausible legislative purpose for their probes, “it is not a court’s ‘function’ to invalidate a congressional investigation,’” U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden wrote in 2021, ruling in favor of a House effort to obtain Trump’s tax returns.

McFadden, a Trump appointee, acknowledged comments from top Democrats, like House Ways and Means Chair Richard Neal and then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi, had muddied the picture, but the judge said even mixed motivations are not enough to undercut Congress’ power.

That principle has held in more than a century of battles between the branches, during which courts —including the Supreme Court — have repeatedly held that the motives of individual members simply can’t overcome the will of the House or a legislative committee when pursuing a legislative goal.

“I wouldn’t dignify this with some counteroffensive in court,” Brand said of Congress’ response to the Trump administration letters. “If these guys try to enforce, it’s going to get flushed.”

Legal, DC, Donald Trump, Robert Garcia, Oversight, Congress