Rule by Press Release: Who Took Away Your Turn to Speak in North Myrtle Beach?

Posted

Starting in January, if you want North Myrtle Beach City Council to hear you, you’ll get one turn at the microphone, before anyone has explained what council is about to decide. And you’ll only get that turn if you signed up online at least three hours ahead [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026].

The city calls this a chance for residents to share their views before council takes up its business [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026]. Plenty of residents are calling it something else: censorship. Is it? The law gives a clear answer. Whether it’s good government is a harder question, and so is the one that matters most right now: who decided this, and what comes next?

What the city announced

Start with the facts. Beginning in January 2027, City Council and the Planning Commission will take public comment during one designated period near the start of each meeting and workshop. Comment will no longer be taken after individual agenda items or at the end of the meeting. Each registered speaker gets one chance, for up to five minutes, on any topic. To speak, you must register online at least three hours beforehand and give your name, address and the subjects you plan to raise [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026].

There is some good news in that. Today, council agendas cap speakers at three minutes and the end-of-meeting comment period at 30 minutes total [City of North Myrtle Beach agenda, 2026]. Five minutes on any subject is more room, not less. But the gain in minutes comes with losses elsewhere, and those losses are the real story.

Is it censorship? Not legally

If “censorship” means breaking the law, the city is probably on safe ground. South Carolina law doesn’t require city councils to offer public comment at all [Municipal Association of SC, n.d.]. The state attorney general has described a council meeting as a limited public forum where councils may set reasonable, viewpoint-neutral limits on time and topic [SC Attorney General, 2023]. A 2025 opinion went further, finding that a council can limit a speaker to a single three-minute turn [SC Attorney General, 2025].

So the rule doesn’t silence any particular opinion. What it does is make every opinion harder to deliver, at a worse moment. That leads to the problem with the new order of business.

Speaking before you’ve heard

Under the current system, a resident can sit through the staff presentation on a rezoning, listen to council’s questions, and then respond. Councilman Bubba Collins noted at a recent meeting that North Myrtle Beach takes comment after every proposed ordinance, which it isn’t required to do, to accommodate the public [MyHorryNews, 2026]. Starting in January, that accommodation ends. Residents will have to speak before staff briefs council and before council debates.

That matters most on land use. State law requires a formal public hearing before a city adopts or amends zoning rules or maps [S.C. Code § 6-29-760]. The city’s announcement doesn’t explain how those required hearings fit into a single comment window at the top of the agenda [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026]. Residents deserve an answer before January, not after the first contested rezoning.

Who decided?

The announcement doesn’t say who approved the change [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026]. The city’s posted results from the Nov. 2 council meeting list annexation, building code, ADU and mobile food vendor items, and nothing on public comment [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026].

Compare that with Bluffton. When that town rewrote its comment rules in 2023, staff put a resolution on the council agenda for a public vote [Town of Bluffton, 2023]. That’s how it should work. In 2023, then-Councilman J.O. Baldwin III said he supported livestreaming meetings “to encourage as much public involvement as possible” [Yahoo News, 2023]. Now Mayor Baldwin presides over a council whose new comment rules arrived by press release. If council voted on this, residents should be told when. If it didn’t, it should, in public, before January.

Who gets left out

The city’s notice mentions only online registration. It says nothing about phone or paper sign-up, written comments, or help for residents without internet access [City of North Myrtle Beach, 2026]. That will hit older residents hardest, along with anyone who comes to City Hall on other business, hears something new and wants to respond.

Other governments manage this differently. Charleston County Council, for example, holds its 30-minute comment period before each regular meeting [Charleston County Council, n.d.]. Taking comment early isn’t the problem. Taking it early, online-only and three hours in advance is.

What’s next

The attorney general’s opinions show how much room councils have: relevancy rules, total time caps and removal of disruptive speakers can all pass legal muster [SC Attorney General, 2023]. That makes it worth watching what comes next. Will the city cap the number of speakers? What will it do with the names, addresses and topics people submit? Will anyone be turned away?

North Myrtle Beach isn’t run by tyrants. But healthy democracy doesn’t usually die in one dramatic vote. It erodes through small procedural changes that make showing up a little harder each time. The fix is simple. Before January, council should vote on these rules in public, add a phone or paper sign-up, accept written comments, and explain how required public hearings will work. Until then, the old rules still apply. Use them: show up and say so.

Further Reading

  • City of North Myrtle Beach, “New Public Comment Process Beginning January 2027” (2026) — https://www.nmb.us/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=1624
  • City of North Myrtle Beach, “Results: November 2 City Council Meeting” (2026) — https://www.nmb.us/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=1610
  • City of North Myrtle Beach, City Council agenda, March 16, 2026 (public comment rules) — https://www.nmb.us/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_03162026-515?html=true
  • WBTW, “North Myrtle Beach to require advance registration to speak at City Council meetings” (2026) — https://www.wbtw.com/news/grand-strand/north-myrtle-beach/north-myrtle-beach-to-require-advance-registration-to-speak-at-city-council-meetings/
  • MyHorryNews, Mike Duprez, “Column: Public comment at North Myrtle Beach City Council meetings could use some tweaks” (2026) — https://www.myhorrynews.com/opinion/column-public-comment-at-north-myrtle-beach-city-council-meetings-could-use-some-tweaks/article_4e8f5c81-5bde-48e6-9d18-e2c435dea694.html
  • Municipal Association of SC, “Public Comment Periods Need Rules and Fairness” — https://www.masc.sc/node/7090
  • Municipal Association of SC, “Cities set own rules for public input during council meetings” — https://www.masc.sc/node/2045
  • SC Attorney General, opinion on rules of conduct for public meetings (Town of Bluffton), June 5, 2023 — https://www.scag.gov/opinions/opinions-archive/opinion-addressing-proposed-rules-of-conduct-for-public-meetings-and-how-a-public-body-may-enforce-those-rules
  • SC Attorney General, opinion on time limits for public speakers, May 27, 2025 — https://www.scag.gov/opinions/opinions-archive/opinion-addressing-a-municipal-council-s-authority-to-limiting-public-speakers-to-a-set-amount-of-time-during-public-comment-at-a-public-meeting/
  • S.C. Code § 6-29-760 (zoning amendments; public hearing) — https://law.justia.com/codes/south-carolina/2013/title-6/chapter-29/section-6-29-760/
  • Town of Bluffton, staff report: Resolution to Adopt New Rules and Protocols for Public Comment (2023) — https://mccmeetingspublic.blob.core.usgovcloudapi.net/blufftonsc-meet-1fd78579e1904c6bbdefbe8670c4341f/ITEM-Attachment-001-9eaeff43e7bf4f2a9c32805fcc8ccbd7.pdf
  • “Will North Myrtle Beach make government even more transparent and accessible?” (2023) — https://news.yahoo.com/north-myrtle-beach-government-even-090000524.html
  • Charleston County Council, Public Comment Statement — https://ccmims.charlestoncounty.gov/Content/PublicCommentStatement/public%20comments%20statement.pdf
News, Editors Choice, Government, NMB