As California Hospice Safeguards Prepare to Expire in January, Health Officials Consider Alternatives

Posted

On January 1st, two of California’s safeguards against hospice fraud will be lifted, raising concerns among lawmakers about a resurgence of hospice fraud. Hospice care is generally intended for patients who have been certified as terminally ill, with a life expectancy of six months or less if their illness follows its normal course, and who elect comfort-focused care rather than treatment intended to cure their terminal illness. Under Medicare, elderly citizens are eligible for a daily rate to cover hospice care, a payment system that can be exploited through fraudulent billing. Fraudulent actors will approach older adults, and entice them into signing up for hospice benefits even when they do not need it. The fraudulent hospice agency will bill Medicare, despite not providing any actual services to the patient, who was not eligible for hospice services in the first place. L.A. County has been described as the epicenter of hospice fraud, and contributed to $100 million in overbilling alone. While L.A. County’s population aged 65 and older grew by 40% between 2010 and 2021, the number of licensed hospice agencies increased by more than 1,500%, according to a report by the California State Auditor in 2022. In 2019, there were 36 hospices per 100,000 people 65 and over in the county, which is more than six times the national average.

In response to the report’s findings, California imposed a moratorium on hospice licenses in 2022, preventing any new hospices from entering the market. Earlier this year, state health officials approved the state’s first-ever hospice licensing rules, which are intended to prevent bad actors from entering the market in the first place. However, both of these safeguards are set to expire on Jan 1, 2027, leaving many worried about the possible return of fraudulent tactics. Last month, state health officials proposed making the hospice licensing rules permanent, which will be heard in a public hearing on Dec 15th. Public comments can be submitted up until the 14th. 

The existing rules aim to prevent fraudulent hospice operations through several requirements:

  1. Management staff, including medical directors, can only work at one hospice at a time, with limited exclusions for rural areas. 
  2. Every hospice must have its own physical building space, with an interior and exterior signage, posted hours, and a 24/7 phone
  3. New hospices must demonstrate, through a state-established formula, that additional hospice care is needed in the service area that they are applying to work in. 
  4. All individuals with a 5% or greater stake in the business, and all management personnel must be disclosed, alongside a 10 year work history. 
  5. If a member of the hospice’s management personnel has received discipline on their license in the past seven years, the new hospice’s license will not be accepted. 
  6. Nurses can be assigned a maximum of 12 patients at a time, and must be able to arrive in-person within two hours of a call, 24 hours a day. 
  7. Hospice licenses cannot change hands within the first five years, to prevent “license flipping.”

While these rules are a good start, a complicated chain of bureaucracy makes enforcement difficult. For example, some hospices may avoid direct inspections by government officials because they use private accrediting organizations, complicating the investigation of complaints. Complaints seen as less serious—which the state has categorized as anything not causing immediate threat to patient safety—are often referred back to the hospice’s private investigator, allowing “ghost” hospices to continue to operate and collect money from Medicare. Joan Teno, a hospice researcher at Brown University’s School of Public Health, says “I am very concerned that flagrant problems were missed, problems as obvious as many hospices listing the same building address in public files.”

The post As California Hospice Safeguards Prepare to Expire in January, Health Officials Consider Alternatives appeared first on LAmag.

Health, California, Fraud, Hospice